The Phanteks NV5 is the objective winner of this comparison, securing six category wins against the single victory held by the Hyte Y70. The most impactful advantage for the Phanteks NV5 is its included fans, which offer a 100% improvement over the competition. While the Hyte Y70 provides a 100% advantage in 3.5" drive bay capacity, it falls behind in the majority of measured specifications, making the Phanteks NV5 the superior choice based on the total spec-win count.

Users prioritizing out-of-the-box cooling should select the Phanteks NV5, as it provides double the fan count compared to the alternative. Conversely, the Hyte Y70 is the better option for builders who require additional storage space, as it offers twice the number of 3.5" bays. Choose the Phanteks NV5 for a more comprehensive hardware package, or opt for the Hyte Y70 if your primary build requirement is maximizing internal drive capacity.